profile

Automate with Heart

A lesson in how *not* to do email marketing

Published about 2 months ago • 2 min read

Enrollment is open for the Subscriber Strategy live training, happening on Tuesday, March 19.

Your consent is super important. Don't want to receive additional promotional emails? Click here to opt out of these emails moving forward.

Hey Reader-

In an effort to do more in-person networking, last year I signed for newsletters at about 8 different business groups in the greater Boston area.

And in a matter of days I was knocked down by a giant wave of emails that flooded my inbox. 🌊

One or two of the groups sent about an email a week. Totally reasonable.

But most sent multiple emails a week without any indication ahead of time they would send this many.

(The worst offender: six emails Monday through Friday. One email. Every. Single. Weekday. Except for Tuesdays, when they sent two. 🤦🏻‍♀️)

Some emails were relevant to me - like the luncheons for women in business or networking coffee hours.

But there was a ton of content that was completely irrelevant and was repeated word-for-word in multiple emails.

The tidal wave of information hitting my inbox - most of which I deleted without even opening - felt both annoying and impersonal.

And if I was feeling this way as someone who has a fair amount of patience for email marketing, I can only imagine how others on their email list were feeling.

It was such a missed opportunity for them….

….to connect with and to get to know their email subscribers
….to write personalized content based on how they identify & what they want to get out of joining these business groups
….to send targeted emails based on whether they’re a member already or not

Doing any of the following to build connection could've made a difference:

🍄 Asking for my consent to receive daily emails (or opting instead to a weekly digest)

🍄 Giving me an option to choose what topics I wanted to hear about

🍄 Inviting me to engage by asking me a question about why I signed up for their email list or what I'd hope to get out of joining the group

🍄 Giving any indication that they got I wasn’t yet a customer

Instead, I just unsubscribed from every single one of these business groups' newsletters and they lost a potential customer.

Take it one step at a time,

Bev

P.S. I imagine part of the reason why you’re here opening (and maybe responding to and/or clicking on these emails) is because you feel some sort of connection with me, Reader.

Part of how I do that is through having a pretty solid (and ever evolving) Subscriber Strategy that allows me to send targeted & personalized emails, instead of treating you like every other subscriber on my email list.

(And if my engagement metrics are any indication, then I’m doing something right! 😉)

That’s why I’m inviting you to join me next Tuesday for the live round of the Subscriber Strategy Training.


Want to fix your name, update your email address, or choose what you hear about? Update your profile

Want to stop receiving all emails from me? Unsubscribe

113 Cherry St #92768, Seattle, WA 98104-2205

Automate with Heart

by Bev Feldman, ConvertKit Consultant + Email Automation Strategist

If you're feeling done with overly aggressive and complicated funnels & one-size-fits-all approaches to email marketing that lack nuance, you're in the right place. Automate with Heart is the only weekly newsletter for established coaches, consultants & service-based business owners who want to be intentional and values-aligned with your email automation strategy.

Share this page